I always find it so funny when people bitch about ‘forced diversity’.
because, like, once you work retail you start to see just how different everybody is.
for example, the other day I greeted a woman I was ringing up and started asking her the usual questions we’re supposed to ask (if they have a rewards card, etc) and she made a gesture pointing to her ear and mouthed ‘I’m deaf’.
and I was just like ‘Oh’, and so I skipped over the questions and just gave her a nice smile instead of the usual schpiel we’re supposed to give. she thanked me in sign language and smiled back before walking away.
and that’s just one tiny example. she was just one customer of hundreds that shift. that’s not even mentioning all the other types of people I ring in a day, of all ages, body sizes, races/skin colors, and gender expression.
it’s like…that’s how the world is.
when people say having diversity in a fictional universe seems ‘false’ or ‘forced’, that says to me that they must exist in a very homogenous, sheltered environment. because even working for a company that has a rather disproportionately-high white middle-class customer demographic, I still see more diversity on any given day than I tend to ever see in books and movies and TV shows.
it’s just kind of laughable to me when people say a movie/book/franchise has “too much” diversity. because there’s no such thing.
When they say diversity is being ‘forced’ they are saying “It’s bad enough I have to tolerate your existence here in this world. I don’t want to have to ever think about you in a fictional one.”
Of course, some of the people saying this live in communities that are 99% one group*. Where any diversity is hidden as well as possible, due to social pressure. My in-laws’ town has age differences, and to a certain extent size differences. Everything else is hidden as well as possible.
My husband didn’t find out he was Autistic until he was 30. Non-white (Mennonite) people don’t move there. No person would admit to being non cisheterosexual unless they had no other options. Poverty is contained in separate neighbourhoods.
People can go weeks without encountering anything noticeably ‘other.’ And they convince themselves that this is what the world is like.
*I noticed after writing this that OP had already mentioned it in passing. Growing up, I didn’t realize homogeneous communities existed. I always get excited to let people know how WEIRD the world is. ‘Some people never see difference!’ But for many people, it’s the opposite that’s a surprise. So sorry if this seems redundant.
(It’s just that I’m white, appear cishet, am a nice Christian girl, thin, English as a first language – and am hopelessly outside these people’s experience. Wrong church denomination, not neurotypical enough, grew up too poor. I grew up in areas SO MUCH more diverse than that. You adapt! The mindset just baffles me. [And the bigotry makes me leave the room and cry in the bathroom.])











